144 lines
26 KiB
Text
144 lines
26 KiB
Text
basic random
|
|
instance size best runtime makespan ecart runtime makespan ecart
|
|
aaa1 2x3 11 1 12 9.1 999 11 0.0
|
|
ft06 6x6 55 0 60 9.1 999 55 0.0
|
|
ft10 10x10 930 0 1319 41.8 999 1209 30.0
|
|
ft20 20x5 1165 0 1672 43.5 999 1529 31.2
|
|
la01 10x5 666 0 858 28.8 999 701 5.3
|
|
la02 10x5 655 0 904 38.0 999 729 11.3
|
|
la03 10x5 597 0 775 29.8 999 673 12.7
|
|
la04 10x5 590 0 854 44.7 999 667 13.1
|
|
la05 10x5 593 0 629 6.1 999 593 0.0
|
|
la06 15x5 926 0 1015 9.6 999 943 1.8
|
|
la07 15x5 890 0 1096 23.1 999 981 10.2
|
|
la08 15x5 863 0 1102 27.7 999 944 9.4
|
|
la09 15x5 951 0 1024 7.7 999 964 1.4
|
|
AVG - - 0.1 - 24.5 999.0 - 9.7
|
|
|
|
|
|
Greedy-SPT Greedy-LRPT Greedy-EST_SPT Greedy-EST_LRPT
|
|
instance size best runtime makespan ecart runtime makespan ecart runtime makespan ecart runtime makespan ecart
|
|
aaa1 2x3 11 6 16 45.5 0 11 0.0 0 11 0.0 1 11 0.0
|
|
ft06 6x6 55 2 108 96.4 2 74 34.5 1 88 60.0 1 61 10.9
|
|
ft10 10x10 930 3 2569 176.2 2 1289 38.6 2 1074 15.5 2 1108 19.1
|
|
ft20 20x5 1165 3 2765 137.3 3 1955 67.8 2 1267 8.8 1 1501 28.8
|
|
la01 10x5 666 1 1464 119.8 0 845 26.9 1 751 12.8 1 735 10.4
|
|
la02 10x5 655 1 1943 196.6 0 982 49.9 0 821 25.3 1 817 24.7
|
|
la03 10x5 597 1 1053 76.4 0 797 33.5 0 672 12.6 0 696 16.6
|
|
la04 10x5 590 1 1491 152.7 0 1000 69.5 1 711 20.5 0 758 28.5
|
|
la05 10x5 593 0 1521 156.5 0 666 12.3 0 610 2.9 0 593 0.0
|
|
la06 15x5 926 1 2372 156.2 1 1151 24.3 0 1200 29.6 0 926 0.0
|
|
la07 15x5 890 1 1823 104.8 1 1108 24.5 1 1034 16.2 1 970 9.0
|
|
la08 15x5 863 0 2309 167.6 0 1196 38.6 1 942 9.2 1 943 9.3
|
|
la09 15x5 951 0 2638 177.4 0 1233 29.7 0 1045 9.9 1 1015 6.7
|
|
AVG - - 1.5 - 135.6 0.7 - 34.6 0.7 - 17.2 0.8 - 12.6
|
|
|
|
|
|
Descent-SPT Descent-LRPT Descent-EST_SPT Descent-EST_LRPT
|
|
instance size best runtime makespan ecart runtime makespan ecart runtime makespan ecart runtime makespan ecart
|
|
aaa1 2x3 11 14 11 0.0 1 11 0.0 1 11 0.0 1 11 0.0
|
|
ft06 6x6 55 21 65 18.2 4 58 5.5 5 72 30.9 3 55 0.0
|
|
ft10 10x10 930 66 1379 48.3 23 1073 15.4 5 1017 9.4 2 1108 19.1
|
|
ft20 20x5 1165 79 1574 35.1 31 1513 29.9 1 1267 8.8 1 1501 28.8
|
|
la01 10x5 666 11 907 36.2 4 666 0.0 2 686 3.0 4 695 4.4
|
|
la02 10x5 655 8 869 32.7 2 806 23.1 3 685 4.6 1 782 19.4
|
|
la03 10x5 597 2 877 46.9 1 725 21.4 0 666 11.6 1 696 16.6
|
|
la04 10x5 590 6 852 44.4 2 794 34.6 1 702 19.0 0 747 26.6
|
|
la05 10x5 593 12 742 25.1 2 621 4.7 0 610 2.9 0 593 0.0
|
|
la06 15x5 926 11 1348 45.6 3 952 2.8 2 963 4.0 0 926 0.0
|
|
la07 15x5 890 14 1087 22.1 3 965 8.4 0 1034 16.2 5 923 3.7
|
|
la08 15x5 863 20 1320 53.0 2 1082 25.4 0 933 8.1 0 909 5.3
|
|
la09 15x5 951 29 1433 50.7 3 1084 14.0 1 975 2.5 1 985 3.6
|
|
AVG - - 22.5 - 35.2 6.2 - 14.2 1.6 - 9.3 1.5 - 9.8
|
|
|
|
|
|
Taboo-EST_LRPT(1,1)
|
|
instance size best runtime makespan ecart
|
|
aaa1 2x3 11 17 11 0.0
|
|
ft06 6x6 55 20 57 3.6
|
|
ft10 10x10 930 13 1108 19.1
|
|
ft20 20x5 1165 9 1501 28.8
|
|
la01 10x5 666 4 695 4.4
|
|
la02 10x5 655 3 803 22.6
|
|
la03 10x5 597 2 696 16.6
|
|
la04 10x5 590 2 747 26.6
|
|
la05 10x5 593 1 593 0.0
|
|
la06 15x5 926 2 926 0.0
|
|
la07 15x5 890 3 951 6.9
|
|
la08 15x5 863 12 909 5.3
|
|
la09 15x5 951 2 985 3.6
|
|
AVG - - 6.9 - 10.6
|
|
|
|
|
|
Taboo-EST_LRPT(1,10) Taboo-EST_LRPT(2,10) Taboo-EST_LRPT(3,10) Taboo-EST_LRPT(4,10) Taboo-EST_LRPT(5,10) Taboo-EST_LRPT(6,10) Taboo-EST_LRPT(7,10) Taboo-EST_LRPT(8,10) Taboo-EST_LRPT(9,10) Taboo-EST_LRPT(10,10)
|
|
instance size best runtime makespan ecart runtime makespan ecart runtime makespan ecart runtime makespan ecart runtime makespan ecart runtime makespan ecart runtime makespan ecart runtime makespan ecart runtime makespan ecart runtime makespan ecart
|
|
aaa1 2x3 11 25 11 0.0 4 11 0.0 4 11 0.0 2 11 0.0 2 11 0.0 2 11 0.0 2 11 0.0 1 11 0.0 2 11 0.0 3 11 0.0
|
|
ft06 6x6 55 14 55 0.0 11 55 0.0 11 55 0.0 7 55 0.0 8 55 0.0 7 55 0.0 6 55 0.0 16 55 0.0 4 55 0.0 4 55 0.0
|
|
ft10 10x10 930 21 1108 19.1 23 1108 19.1 19 1096 17.8 14 1108 19.1 19 1108 19.1 14 1108 19.1 12 1108 19.1 11 1108 19.1 11 1108 19.1 11 1108 19.1
|
|
ft20 20x5 1165 7 1501 28.8 7 1465 25.8 8 1465 25.8 15 1465 25.8 5 1465 25.8 4 1465 25.8 5 1465 25.8 5 1465 25.8 5 1465 25.8 5 1465 25.8
|
|
la01 10x5 666 4 695 4.4 2 692 3.9 3 692 3.9 2 692 3.9 3 692 3.9 2 692 3.9 2 692 3.9 2 692 3.9 2 692 3.9 2 692 3.9
|
|
la02 10x5 655 3 769 17.4 3 769 17.4 3 769 17.4 2 753 15.0 2 753 15.0 3 753 15.0 3 753 15.0 2 753 15.0 2 753 15.0 3 753 15.0
|
|
la03 10x5 597 2 692 15.9 2 692 15.9 6 689 15.4 2 689 15.4 2 692 15.9 4 692 15.9 3 692 15.9 2 692 15.9 3 692 15.9 2 692 15.9
|
|
la04 10x5 590 3 696 18.0 2 696 18.0 3 696 18.0 2 696 18.0 2 702 19.0 2 703 19.2 2 703 19.2 1 694 17.6 2 694 17.6 2 694 17.6
|
|
la05 10x5 593 3 593 0.0 2 593 0.0 1 593 0.0 1 593 0.0 1 593 0.0 1 593 0.0 1 593 0.0 1 593 0.0 1 593 0.0 1 593 0.0
|
|
la06 15x5 926 2 926 0.0 2 926 0.0 2 926 0.0 2 926 0.0 2 926 0.0 2 926 0.0 1 926 0.0 3 926 0.0 2 926 0.0 1 926 0.0
|
|
la07 15x5 890 7 912 2.5 5 912 2.5 4 912 2.5 8 912 2.5 4 912 2.5 4 912 2.5 5 912 2.5 4 912 2.5 4 912 2.5 4 912 2.5
|
|
la08 15x5 863 4 902 4.5 4 902 4.5 5 902 4.5 4 902 4.5 8 902 4.5 6 902 4.5 5 902 4.5 4 902 4.5 3 902 4.5 3 902 4.5
|
|
la09 15x5 951 3 951 0.0 2 951 0.0 3 951 0.0 15 985 3.6 6 985 3.6 5 951 0.0 4 951 0.0 4 951 0.0 4 951 0.0 6 951 0.0
|
|
AVG - - 7.5 - 8.5 5.3 - 8.2 5.5 - 8.1 5.8 - 8.3 4.9 - 8.4 4.3 - 8.1 3.9 - 8.1 4.3 - 8.0 3.5 - 8.0 3.6 - 8.0
|
|
|
|
|
|
Taboo-EST_LRPT(1,100) Taboo-EST_LRPT(6,100) Taboo-EST_LRPT(8,100) Taboo-EST_LRPT(10,100) Taboo-EST_LRPT(12,100) Taboo-EST_LRPT(14,100) Taboo-EST_LRPT(20,100) Taboo-EST_LRPT(50,100) Taboo-EST_LRPT(100,100)
|
|
instance size best runtime makespan ecart runtime makespan ecart runtime makespan ecart runtime makespan ecart runtime makespan ecart runtime makespan ecart runtime makespan ecart runtime makespan ecart runtime makespan ecart
|
|
aaa1 2x3 11 48 11 0.0 13 11 0.0 9 11 0.0 6 11 0.0 5 11 0.0 5 11 0.0 3 11 0.0 2 11 0.0 3 11 0.0
|
|
ft06 6x6 55 43 55 0.0 36 55 0.0 27 55 0.0 20 55 0.0 20 55 0.0 15 55 0.0 17 55 0.0 10 55 0.0 6 55 0.0
|
|
ft10 10x10 930 95 1108 19.1 63 1037 11.5 59 1041 11.9 52 1032 11.0 60 1048 12.7 82 1046 12.5 55 1054 13.3 48 1098 18.1 34 1098 18.1
|
|
ft20 20x5 1165 42 1501 28.8 40 1329 14.1 41 1329 14.1 46 1311 12.5 37 1325 13.7 43 1329 14.1 51 1352 16.1 23 1399 20.1 18 1400 20.2
|
|
la01 10x5 666 23 695 4.4 9 666 0.0 7 666 0.0 19 666 0.0 16 690 3.6 13 688 3.3 15 671 0.8 8 690 3.6 6 692 3.9
|
|
la02 10x5 655 34 737 12.5 17 722 10.2 22 694 6.0 15 706 7.8 16 732 11.8 13 736 12.4 11 736 12.4 9 736 12.4 11 745 13.7
|
|
la03 10x5 597 21 692 15.9 21 651 9.0 21 676 13.2 17 637 6.7 15 678 13.6 16 670 12.2 14 617 3.4 10 648 8.5 7 692 15.9
|
|
la04 10x5 590 21 696 18.0 22 638 8.1 26 646 9.5 23 648 9.8 14 639 8.3 14 651 10.3 12 647 9.7 9 674 14.2 5 674 14.2
|
|
la05 10x5 593 11 593 0.0 8 593 0.0 8 593 0.0 5 593 0.0 5 593 0.0 5 593 0.0 4 593 0.0 4 593 0.0 5 593 0.0
|
|
la06 15x5 926 31 926 0.0 11 926 0.0 8 926 0.0 8 926 0.0 8 926 0.0 8 926 0.0 11 926 0.0 7 926 0.0 7 926 0.0
|
|
la07 15x5 890 33 890 0.0 14 890 0.0 13 890 0.0 17 890 0.0 11 890 0.0 15 890 0.0 11 890 0.0 10 890 0.0 11 890 0.0
|
|
la08 15x5 863 30 902 4.5 22 863 0.0 25 866 0.3 23 863 0.0 24 863 0.0 21 863 0.0 14 863 0.0 13 878 1.7 8 902 4.5
|
|
la09 15x5 951 15 951 0.0 11 951 0.0 11 951 0.0 9 951 0.0 8 951 0.0 9 951 0.0 23 951 0.0 13 951 0.0 13 951 0.0
|
|
AVG - - 34.4 - 7.9 22.1 - 4.1 21.3 - 4.2 20.0 - 3.7 18.4 - 4.9 19.9 - 5.0 18.5 - 4.3 12.8 - 6.0 10.3 - 7.0
|
|
|
|
|
|
Taboo-EST_LRPT(1,1000) Taboo-EST_LRPT(6,1000) Taboo-EST_LRPT(8,1000) Taboo-EST_LRPT(10,1000) Taboo-EST_LRPT(12,1000) Taboo-EST_LRPT(14,1000) Taboo-EST_LRPT(20,1000) Taboo-EST_LRPT(50,1000) Taboo-EST_LRPT(100,1000)
|
|
instance size best runtime makespan ecart runtime makespan ecart runtime makespan ecart runtime makespan ecart runtime makespan ecart runtime makespan ecart runtime makespan ecart runtime makespan ecart runtime makespan ecart
|
|
aaa1 2x3 11 99 11 0.0 24 11 0.0 23 11 0.0 25 11 0.0 24 11 0.0 21 11 0.0 18 11 0.0 14 11 0.0 12 11 0.0
|
|
ft06 6x6 55 160 55 0.0 137 55 0.0 133 55 0.0 99 55 0.0 103 55 0.0 76 55 0.0 73 55 0.0 49 55 0.0 55 55 0.0
|
|
ft10 10x10 930 583 1108 19.1 622 1013 8.9 569 983 5.7 541 978 5.2 573 978 5.2 530 1007 8.3 535 1029 10.6 360 1045 12.4 251 1015 9.1
|
|
ft20 20x5 1165 383 1501 28.8 396 1217 4.5 438 1262 8.3 366 1243 6.7 294 1255 7.7 321 1218 4.5 302 1219 4.6 209 1246 7.0 168 1271 9.1
|
|
la01 10x5 666 196 695 4.4 61 666 0.0 52 666 0.0 64 666 0.0 65 666 0.0 76 666 0.0 68 666 0.0 52 666 0.0 54 666 0.0
|
|
la02 10x5 655 244 737 12.5 170 667 1.8 177 665 1.5 158 665 1.5 142 662 1.1 134 655 0.0 108 671 2.4 69 692 5.6 58 720 9.9
|
|
la03 10x5 597 165 692 15.9 133 628 5.2 152 620 3.9 143 603 1.0 140 603 1.0 130 603 1.0 108 603 1.0 76 615 3.0 56 615 3.0
|
|
la04 10x5 590 203 696 18.0 129 638 8.1 160 598 1.4 151 599 1.5 148 604 2.4 75 637 8.0 104 597 1.2 91 620 5.1 72 620 5.1
|
|
la05 10x5 593 93 593 0.0 56 593 0.0 59 593 0.0 49 593 0.0 49 593 0.0 45 593 0.0 45 593 0.0 45 593 0.0 40 593 0.0
|
|
la06 15x5 926 169 926 0.0 90 926 0.0 80 926 0.0 82 926 0.0 77 926 0.0 72 926 0.0 76 926 0.0 64 926 0.0 65 926 0.0
|
|
la07 15x5 890 164 890 0.0 92 890 0.0 94 890 0.0 84 890 0.0 82 890 0.0 79 890 0.0 81 890 0.0 69 890 0.0 72 890 0.0
|
|
la08 15x5 863 326 902 4.5 103 863 0.0 105 863 0.0 90 863 0.0 92 863 0.0 82 863 0.0 82 863 0.0 72 863 0.0 72 863 0.0
|
|
la09 15x5 951 151 951 0.0 85 951 0.0 81 951 0.0 80 951 0.0 79 951 0.0 78 951 0.0 78 951 0.0 78 951 0.0 62 951 0.0
|
|
AVG - - 225.8 - 7.9 161.4 - 2.2 163.3 - 1.6 148.6 - 1.2 143.7 - 1.3 132.2 - 1.7 129.1 - 1.5 96.0 - 2.5 79.8 - 2.8
|
|
|
|
|
|
Taboo-EST_LRPT(1,5000) Taboo-EST_LRPT(6,5000) Taboo-EST_LRPT(8,5000) Taboo-EST_LRPT(10,5000) Taboo-EST_LRPT(12,5000) Taboo-EST_LRPT(14,5000) Taboo-EST_LRPT(20,5000) Taboo-EST_LRPT(50,5000) Taboo-EST_LRPT(100,5000)
|
|
instance size best runtime makespan ecart runtime makespan ecart runtime makespan ecart runtime makespan ecart runtime makespan ecart runtime makespan ecart runtime makespan ecart runtime makespan ecart runtime makespan ecart
|
|
aaa1 2x3 11 265 11 0.0 101 11 0.0 40 11 0.0 34 11 0.0 35 11 0.0 27 11 0.0 38 11 0.0 25 11 0.0 30 11 0.0
|
|
ft06 6x6 55 675 55 0.0 665 55 0.0 405 55 0.0 504 55 0.0 489 55 0.0 329 55 0.0 286 55 0.0 267 55 0.0 222 55 0.0
|
|
ft10 10x10 930 1000 1108 19.1 1000 1002 7.7 1000 954 2.6 1000 978 5.2 1000 976 4.9 1000 995 7.0 1000 1007 8.3 1000 1036 11.4 1000 1015 9.1
|
|
ft20 20x5 1165 1000 1501 28.8 1000 1217 4.5 1000 1262 8.3 1000 1193 2.4 1000 1255 7.7 1000 1192 2.3 1000 1187 1.9 1000 1189 2.1 699 1240 6.4
|
|
la01 10x5 666 999 695 4.4 320 666 0.0 278 666 0.0 273 666 0.0 274 666 0.0 280 666 0.0 255 666 0.0 240 666 0.0 242 666 0.0
|
|
la02 10x5 655 1000 737 12.5 959 667 1.8 722 660 0.8 612 655 0.0 604 658 0.5 620 655 0.0 473 655 0.0 420 660 0.8 329 669 2.1
|
|
la03 10x5 597 891 692 15.9 510 628 5.2 690 605 1.3 380 603 1.0 690 603 1.0 329 603 1.0 440 603 1.0 414 615 3.0 278 615 3.0
|
|
la04 10x5 590 1000 696 18.0 710 638 8.1 677 598 1.4 382 599 1.5 477 602 2.0 339 637 8.0 381 597 1.2 446 598 1.4 332 616 4.4
|
|
la05 10x5 593 504 593 0.0 302 593 0.0 278 593 0.0 271 593 0.0 250 593 0.0 249 593 0.0 252 593 0.0 214 593 0.0 223 593 0.0
|
|
la06 15x5 926 794 926 0.0 471 926 0.0 412 926 0.0 417 926 0.0 406 926 0.0 391 926 0.0 367 926 0.0 360 926 0.0 338 926 0.0
|
|
la07 15x5 890 787 890 0.0 462 890 0.0 477 890 0.0 474 890 0.0 474 890 0.0 421 890 0.0 395 890 0.0 373 890 0.0 381 890 0.0
|
|
la08 15x5 863 1000 902 4.5 473 863 0.0 455 863 0.0 445 863 0.0 421 863 0.0 411 863 0.0 387 863 0.0 372 863 0.0 351 863 0.0
|
|
la09 15x5 951 786 951 0.0 482 951 0.0 453 951 0.0 426 951 0.0 406 951 0.0 392 951 0.0 388 951 0.0 367 951 0.0 357 951 0.0
|
|
AVG - - 823.2 - 7.9 573.5 - 2.1 529.8 - 1.1 478.3 - 0.8 502.0 - 1.2 445.2 - 1.4 435.5 - 1.0 422.9 - 1.4 367.8 - 1.9
|
|
|
|
|